Man City view on charges is being forgotten amid Everton FFP fury

It seems a long nine months since it was interpreted by many that Manchester City were being made an example of by a Premier League looking to show it had the teeth to effectively regulate itself and its members.

The timing of the unprecedented charges against the champions raised many an eyebrow – including at the Etihad – yet fast-forward to now and City have seemingly become the establishment, ‘escaping punishment’ (or, more accurately, still awaiting verdict in a more complex case) while Everton are the ones publicly humiliated to send a message to the rest of the league and the corridors of government. The unexpected severity of the 10-point penalty has ramped up talk of the huge ramifications City could face if the most serious charges against them are proven.

However, to quote Pep Guardiola from his first press conference after the news back in February, “what happens if we are innocent?” The allegations against the Blues are so grave that they will need to be backed up to a high degree of proof, and the last governing body that believed they had City bang to rights got a rude awakening when the evidence was presented before an independent panel.

Guardiola reviews Man City’s draw at Chelsea

So while it is true that the most serious charges against City could (and should) result in expulsion from the league, nobody has seen any evidence to suggest it is likely to happen. Anyone who can tell you what the independent panel are going to decide is telling you a lie, because there are far too many unknowns.

Going back to that Guardiola press conference, he revealed that his bosses Ferran Soriano and Khaldoon Al Mubarak were “more confident” of being cleared of the charges on the basis of their ‘experience and information’. That leaves the potential for City to have serious egg on their face, but it comes from people who have been vindicated in a similar matter where the stakes were also high.

If the strictest punishments can be hypothesised, so too can the softest. The reasoning behind the Everton verdict would indicate that City will do well to avoid charges of not co-operating for the investigation, which was the only charge that stuck from UEFA in the Court of Arbitration for Sport; the Blues were given a fine of 10 million euros, which was both hefty but also reduced from the 30 million they had initially been ordered to pay.

Promoted Stories

That may well be enough for some to claim that City are guilty (as they have done after CAS) but it would be harsh to punish a lack of co-operation with anything bigger than a fine – particularly if the most serious charges from a five-year investigation do not stick. As two leading academics on the subject wrote in a paper shared with the Manchester Evening News: “It would not be good enough for the Premier League to argue that Manchester City failed to co-operate with the Premier League’s investigation.”

City getting off the most serious charges, and getting off more lightly than Everton, would cause uproar among clubs expecting and hoping that the Blues will be punished and leave the Premier League with serious questions about how it has treated one of its most valuable assets.

As with CAS though, the independent panel can only judge the evidence they are presented with and if it is important to know the worst possible scenarios for City then the club’s confidence in being exonerated should not be forgotten either. What happens if City are not guilty of their most serious allegations is arguably a messier outcome than expulsion, but should be considered as real a possibility.

Related Posts

‘Wasted money’… Harry Redknapp says 22-year-old Chelsea player is ‘very average’

Harry Redknapp has strongly criticised Chelsea for spending so much on “very average” attacker Mykhailo Mudryk.

Man Utd want €40m-rated ace with 15 goal contributions, but he prefers Arsenal | CaughtOffside

Arsenal have been linked with the move for the Bayer Leverkusen defender Jeremie Frimpong. The 22-year-old is reportedly a target for Manchester United as well. But a report from Football Transfers claims that he prefers a move to Arsenal instead. The defender could be signed for a fee of around €40 million at the end …

Matheus Nunes says Guardiola has an incredible teenager on his hands at Man City

Matheus Nunes has now heaped praise on Manchester City No.82 Rico Lewis – as well as some of his other teammates. The 25-year-old spoke to Sky Sports…

Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp on how he’ll replace Mohamed Salah in January

Jurgen Klopp address Mohamed Salah’s looming January departure to the Africa Cup of Nations

Chelsea confirm £29m player is no longer injured ahead of Everton fixture

Will he play on Sunday?

Man Utd fighting £34m transfer battle over La Liga star as Rashford challenged

Manchester United are preparing for what could be a busy January transfer window following the long-awaited arrival of Sir Jim Ratcliffe, with targets already being identified

Trả lời

Email của bạn sẽ không được hiển thị công khai. Các trường bắt buộc được đánh dấu *